September 2009 Public Forum Resources: Immigration Policy

Written by Jason Neiffer

Sunday, 23 August 2009 00:00

PURCHASE AND DOWNLOAD RIGHT NOW!! Big Sky Debate is pleased to release its September 2009 Public Forums resources on immigration policy! The resolution, released by the National Forensics League on August 15, 2009, is:

Resolved: United States policy on illegal immigration should focus on attrition through enforcement rather than amnesty.

The index for our resources is here and a list of briefs for this book appears below the fold.

Why pay for the same immigration back files from the others? Big Sky Debate's immigration resources ACTUALLY consider the resolutional terms "attrition through enforcement" (a specific phrase in immigration literature) and "amesty."

While we know our Public Forum resources is a bargain at $12, why not subscribe now for a whole season at just $50? Compare similar services without Big Sky Debate's seasoned research staff at THREE times that cost!

Have a great season!! Our Public Forum Resources are an unbeatable $12.00

METADEBATE

ATTRITION THROUGH ENFORCEMENT DEFINED
IMMIGRANTS INCREASING
AMNESTY IS AN UNCLEAR/OBSCURING POLICY TERM

PRO EVIDENCE

IMMIGRANTS OVERSTRESS THE HEALTH CARE SYSTEM
IMMIGRANTS OVERSTRESS THE EDUCATIONAL SYSTEM
IMMIGRANTS OVERSTRESS THE PUBLIC WELFARE SYSTEM
IMMIGRANTS INCREASE CRIME
IMMIGRANTS RISK NATIONAL SECURITY
IMMIGRANTS/OPEN IMMIGRATION HURTS JOB MARKET
ATTRITION THROUGH ENFORCEMENT SOLVES: SHOULD ENFORCE IMMIGRATION LAWS
ATTRITION THROUGH ENFORCEMENT SOLVES: DECREASES ILLEGAL IMMIGRANTS
ATTRITION THROUGH ENFORCEMENT SOLVES: EMPIRICALLY WORKS
ATTRITION THROUGH ENFORCEMENT SOLVES: LOW COST POLICY
ATTRITION THROUGH ENFORCEMENT SOLVES: SHOULD USE LOCAL LAW ENFORCEMENT
ATTRITION THROUGH ENFORCEMENT SOLVES: DECREASES CRIME
SANCTUARY LAWS: THE OPPOSITE OF ATTRITION THROUGH ENFORCEMENT
SANCTUARY LAWS: HURT ENFORCEMENT OF IMMIGRATION LAWS AT FEDERAL LEVEL
SANCTUARY LAWS: INCREASE CRIMINAL ACTIVITY IN CITIES
AMNESTY INVITES TERRORISM
AMNESTY INVITES MORE ILLEGAL IMMIGRATION
AMNESTY MOCKS THE RULE OF LAW/LAW ABIDING FOLKS
AMNESTY WOULD OVERWHELM PUBLIC SERVICES
GUEST WORKER PROGRAMS FAIL
GUEST WORK PROGRAMS INCREASE ILLEGAL IMMIGRATION
GUEST WORKER PROGRAMS HURT IMMIGRANTS
SANCTUARY CITIES INVITE TERRORISM
A/T: IMMIGRANTS NEED RIGHTS/ARE ABUSED
A/T: MORALITY DEMANDS CON
A/T: ATTRITION THROUGH ENFORCEMENT CRITICISM

CON EVIDENCE

AMNESTY IS GOOD
AMNESTY COMBATS RACISM
AMNESTY PROTECTS IMMIGRANT RIGHTS
AMNESTY ACKNOWLEDGES HUMAN BONDS MADE BY IMMIGRANTS
AMNESTY INCREASES THE TAX REVENUE COLLECTED IN THE UNITED STATES
AMNESTY INCREASES US NATIONAL SECURITY
AMNESTY/IMMIGRANTS HELP US ECONOMY
AMNESTY IS THE MORAL OPTIONS
ANTI-AMNESTY SOURCES ARE BIASED
GUEST WORKER PROGRAMS SOLVE
ATTRITION THROUGH ENFORCEMENT FAILS TO SOLVE IMMIGRATION
ATTRITION THROUGH ENFORCEMENT FAILS: WON’T SCALE TO NATIONAL POLICY
ATTRITION THROUGH ENFORCEMENT FAILS: UTILIZING POLICE FOR IMMIGRATION FAILS
ATTRITION THROUGH ENFORCEMENTS FAILS: LACKING FEDERAL RESOURCES/BAD IMMIGRATION LAWS DOOMS POLICY
ATTRITION THROUGH ENFORCEMENT: LEADS TO RACISM PROFILING
ATTRITION THROUGH ENFORCEMENT: MEANS POOR IMMIGRANT/POLICY RELATIONS
ATTRITION THROUGH ENFORCEMENT: STRONG IMMIGRATION LAW ENFORCEMENT FAILS
ATTRITION THROUGH ENFORCEMENT FAILS: WILL HURT US AG INDUSTRY
ATTRITION THROUGH ENFORCEMENT FAILS: DECREASES PRIVACY
ATTRITION THROUGH ENFORCEMENT: = SOCIALISM… SERIOUSLY!
SANCTUARY CITIES: MEAN LESS CRIME
SANCTUARY CITIES: MEAN COMBATING RACISM
SANCTUARY CITIES: MEAN BETTER POLICING THROUGH COMMUNITY POLICING
SANCTUARY CITIES: MAKE COMMUNITIES BETTER
SHOULD INCREASE IMMIGRATION/IMMIGRATION NOT A PROBLEM
A/T: AMNESTY = MORE ILLEGAL IMMIGRATION
A/T: FAIRNESS/RULE OF LAW ARGUMENTS
A/T: IMMIGRANTS DO/WOULD STRESS HEALTH CARE SYSTEM
A/T: IMMIGRANTS DO/WOULD STRESS EDUCATIONAL SYSTEM
A/T: IMMIGRANTS DO/WOULD STRESS CRIMINAL JUSTICE SYSTEM
A/T: AMNESTY/IMMIGRANTS DRAIN PUBLIC SERVICE FUNDING
A/T: IMMIGRANT TERRORISM ARGUMENTS